So the whole "literary debate" was really a load of nonsense. George Will argues in favor of Carol Iannone being nominated as chairwoman to some stuffy committee for something academic, and berates the MLA (an already cursed name to students) because the y demean her as being too "political" in favor of a majority now viewed as distasteful, and that esentially all literature is political on those grounds, and therefore biased, and thus not of cultural merit. Will mocks this idea with sardonic refrences to classic texts in the views of those MLA types who disregard them for their subversive support of "those who were in power" and are now for some reason presently in the wrong. He calls it, and I wholeheartedly agree. a study of victimology, wherein a work's cultural significance is devalued if it does not exalt those who were supposedly victimized in its era of origin (ie "The Tempest" and its pro-colonialist message is considered of lesser merit and too political because of such a message). He attacks these groups for nursing grievances and demanding entitlements for their so-called past oppresion (such as feminism in literature, as well as race and patriarchial sex roles). He also opposes those who deny the "autonomy of culture" in that no one writes out of true creativity, they are only reflections of the opinions of dominant parties in power, and that in these present days academia has degraded into a system that is determined to establish curriculm and bestowing honors based on sexual and racial grounds so as to make reparations for Western civilizations sins, and has consequently begun to eradicate the importance of true esthectical value. The entire system "aims at delegitimizing Western civilization by discrediting the books and ideas that gave birth to it." Well said, brother, well said. Heck, the MLA probably burns effigies of Rudyard Kipling 'cause of all he wrote. But the truly ironic thing about this whole "debate" is that the second writer, Stephen Greenblatt, isn't negating or really debating what Will was talking about! He picks out a few more heated lines (relating the MLA to terrorists or some other rubbish) and openly mocks it in a way that seems like he takes it entirely too personally, and, after establishing a clearly hostile and demeaning view of Will, goes on to make a point that is not entirely connected to Will's article. Greenblatt attacks Will for wanting too uniform a curriculum that has no appreciation for "the painful and messy struggle over rights and values, political and sexual and ethical dilemmas that great art has taken upon itself to articulate and grapple with". That is exactly what Will was supporting, he was simply discussing how many academic organizations want to demean these struggles by labeling them too political and thus not as worthy because they victimized certain parties. Greenblatt realized the injustices society has made, but those have made art and literature signifacant to culture, and have even made up the culture, something Will expressed was important as well. It is clear Greenblatt desired to oppose Will on grounds unrelated to the article in question as, philosophically, they hardly disagreed. And that is what I got out of this high-spoken bunch of hogwash and pretty much crap.Monday, October 4, 2010
Why we should all just stop trying to disagree with each other...
So the whole "literary debate" was really a load of nonsense. George Will argues in favor of Carol Iannone being nominated as chairwoman to some stuffy committee for something academic, and berates the MLA (an already cursed name to students) because the y demean her as being too "political" in favor of a majority now viewed as distasteful, and that esentially all literature is political on those grounds, and therefore biased, and thus not of cultural merit. Will mocks this idea with sardonic refrences to classic texts in the views of those MLA types who disregard them for their subversive support of "those who were in power" and are now for some reason presently in the wrong. He calls it, and I wholeheartedly agree. a study of victimology, wherein a work's cultural significance is devalued if it does not exalt those who were supposedly victimized in its era of origin (ie "The Tempest" and its pro-colonialist message is considered of lesser merit and too political because of such a message). He attacks these groups for nursing grievances and demanding entitlements for their so-called past oppresion (such as feminism in literature, as well as race and patriarchial sex roles). He also opposes those who deny the "autonomy of culture" in that no one writes out of true creativity, they are only reflections of the opinions of dominant parties in power, and that in these present days academia has degraded into a system that is determined to establish curriculm and bestowing honors based on sexual and racial grounds so as to make reparations for Western civilizations sins, and has consequently begun to eradicate the importance of true esthectical value. The entire system "aims at delegitimizing Western civilization by discrediting the books and ideas that gave birth to it." Well said, brother, well said. Heck, the MLA probably burns effigies of Rudyard Kipling 'cause of all he wrote. But the truly ironic thing about this whole "debate" is that the second writer, Stephen Greenblatt, isn't negating or really debating what Will was talking about! He picks out a few more heated lines (relating the MLA to terrorists or some other rubbish) and openly mocks it in a way that seems like he takes it entirely too personally, and, after establishing a clearly hostile and demeaning view of Will, goes on to make a point that is not entirely connected to Will's article. Greenblatt attacks Will for wanting too uniform a curriculum that has no appreciation for "the painful and messy struggle over rights and values, political and sexual and ethical dilemmas that great art has taken upon itself to articulate and grapple with". That is exactly what Will was supporting, he was simply discussing how many academic organizations want to demean these struggles by labeling them too political and thus not as worthy because they victimized certain parties. Greenblatt realized the injustices society has made, but those have made art and literature signifacant to culture, and have even made up the culture, something Will expressed was important as well. It is clear Greenblatt desired to oppose Will on grounds unrelated to the article in question as, philosophically, they hardly disagreed. And that is what I got out of this high-spoken bunch of hogwash and pretty much crap.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You should tell us how you really feel. Don't hold back so much . . .
ReplyDeleteYou mention how, "That is exactly what Will was supporting, he was simply discussing how many academic organizations want to demean these struggles by labeling them too political and thus not as worthy because they victimized certain parties." Actually, George Will was arguing that politics should have no place in the discussion. We should just passively accept information without interrogating it--only look at its aesthetic appeal. But Greenblatt wants us to critically examine things and pay attention to the political dimensions of a text.
Even if it is indeed hogwash, there's definitely a direct opposition between the two.